All-City (Indianapolis Star and News)
| 1972 |
Dick Nalley, RB; Bert Stahley, LB |
| 1975 |
Matt Carrico, LB; Chad Huck, QB; Bob Kocher, WR; Ed Perry, P; Tony Young, T |
| 1976 |
Tim Dant, DT; Jack Hawkins, G; Chad Huck, QB; Jeff Jourdan, WR, Steve Stevason, DE |
| 1977 |
Lou Annee, P; Mark Jahnke, T |
| 1978 |
Mike Perry, WR |
| 1979 |
Duane Lutgring, T; Bob Woods, G |
| 1980 |
John Kennedy, QB |
| 1981 |
Jeff Brown, G; Dan Corsaro, DB; Andy Mappes, C-MG |
| 1982 |
Greg Corsaro, LB; Kenny Gillum, RB; Andy Mappes, C-MG |
| 1983 |
Tim Annee, DB; Dan Bauer, MG; Jim House, T; Bryan Kalen, DB; Pat Spencer, G |
| 1984 |
Tim Annee, DB; Dan Bauer, G; Glen Huffman, TE; Pat Spencer, G |
| 1985 |
Steve Clements, T; Joe Gillum, BB; Mike Irmer, DB; Marty Sedgwick, C |
| 1986 |
Eric Schott, T; Tony Farrell, DB; Mike Irmer, DB; Mark Heisig |
| 1987 |
Mike Gillum, LB; Doug Hagist, DT |
| 1988 |
Jim Roeder, OT; Andy Tingle, QB; Bob Spicuzza, WR; Javier Zuluaga, LB; Stan Lawrie, RB |
| 1989 |
Chris Toner, LB; Stan Lawrie, RB; Brian Sander, DE; John Roeder, OT, Brian Irish, DB |
| 1990 |
Chris Toner, LB; Brian Sanders, DE; John Roeder, OT |
| 1991 |
Ray Shelburn, LB; Joe Lawrie, TE |
| 1992 |
Brian Zuwicki, DE; Matt Evans, QB; James Kelso, RB; Christian Gaskill, LB; Andy Roell, OT |
| 1993 |
Mike Bohn, RB; Jason Hasty, OT; Jason Simmons, OT; Joe Shelborn, C; Christian Gaskill, LB; Mike Tinder, PK; Andy Roell, DT; Craig Cothron, DB |
| 1994 |
Brian Lauck, DB; Nick Scott, DT; Dan Elsener, TE; Jerermy Stahley, LB; Jeff Allard, DT |
| 1995 |
Jeff Roell, RB; Jeff Allard, OT; Chris Harvey, LB; Nick Kidwell, RB; Nick Long, PK; Joe Weber, OT |
| 1996 |
Dan Driscoll, OG; Andy Elsener, LB; David Himes, DB; Aaron Irwin, OT; Nick Long, PK; Sean Schembra, RB |
| 1997 |
David Armbruster, OT; Malcolm Harmon, DB; Sean Schembra, RB; Adam Stephenson, QB |
| 1998 |
Steve Eckhart, LB; John Harrington, DB; Jeff Jourdan, WR; Eddie Keller, DT; Chris Price, LB; Patrick Schaub, RB; Dan Taylor, DB |
All-County (Indianapolis Star)
| 1999 |
Ryan Brizendine, DT; Tommy Schembra, RB; Mike Williams, Punter |
| 2000 |
Jimmy Harrington, LB |
| 2001 |
Tommy Kraft, LB |
| 2002 |
Marcus Nalley, RB; Vince Logan, OT; Kyle Stephenson, DB; Peter Szostak, DE; Nick Johnson, Punter |
| 2003 |
Mark Evans, OG; Tim Sergi, RB |
| 2004 |
Jason Werner, DB; Taylor Donnell, TE; Casey Bolsega, OT; Pat Kuntz, DE |
| 2005 |
Brandon Axum, DB; Will Roush, OT; Steve Wilson, DE |
| 2006 |
Joe Britner, TE; Kyle Danhauer, LB |
| 2007 |
Jack Hawkins, OT; John Keevers, LB |
| 2008 |
Weston Kitley, OT; Drew Oechsle, LB |
| 2009 |
Luke Burkhart, DL; Matt Masengale, OT |
All-Metro (Indianapolis Star and News)
| 1983 |
Joe Annee, LB; Dan Bauer, MG; Jim House, T; Pat Spencer, G |
| 1984 |
Tim Annee, P; Dan Bauer, G; Joe Gillum, RB; Glen Huffman, RE; Sean Sanders, T |
| 1985 |
Steve Clements, T; Joe Gillum, RB; Mike Irmer, DB; Jim Padgett, LB; Ron Roembke, DE |
| 1986 |
Eric Schott |
| 1987 |
Mike Gillum, RB; Dan Poore, DL |
| 1988 |
Jim Roeder, OT; Javier Zuluaga, LB; Stan Lawrie, RB |
| 1989 |
Stan Lawrie, RB; Chris Toner, LB; Brian Sanders, DE |
| 1990 |
Brian Sanders, DE; John Roeder, OT |
| 1993 |
Jason Simmons, OT; Mike Bohn, RB; Joe Shelborn, C; Andy Roell, NG; Christian Gaskill, LB; Mike Tinder, PK |
| 1994 |
Jeremy Stanley, LB; Brian Lauck, DB; Rick Scott, TE |
| 1995 |
Jeff Roell, RB; Jeff Allard, OT; Chris Harvey, LB |
| 1996 |
Sean Schembra, RB |
| 1997 |
Sean Schembra, RB; David Armbruster, OT |
| 1998 |
Pat Schaub, RB; Eddie Keller, DT; Dan Taylor, DB |
| 1999 |
Ryan Brizendine |
| 2002 |
Marcus Nalley, RB; Vince Logan, OT |
| 2003 |
Mark Evans, OG |
| 2004 |
Pat Kuntz, DE; Jason Werner, DB |
| 2005 |
Brandon Axum, DB |
| 2006 |
Kyle Danhauer, LB |
| 2007 |
Jack Hawkins, OT |
| 2008 |
Drew Oechsle, LB |
| 2009 |
Matt Masengale, OT |
Academic All-State (Indiana Football Coaches Association)
| 1981 |
Dan Corsaro |
| 1982 |
Greg Corsaro |
| 1983 |
Pat Spencer |
| 1984 |
Brian Hogan |
| 1985 |
Ron Roembke |
| 1986 |
Dave Henn |
| 1988 |
Dan Schoettle |
| 1989 |
Mike Pierle, Stan Lawrie |
| 1991 |
Mark Henninger |
| 1993 |
Christian Gaskill, Andy Roell |
| 1996 |
Josh Blanchard, John Hollowell, Chris Perkins, Lucas Schroeder |
| 1998 |
David Perkins, Josh Fredlake, Steve Eckhart, Chris Price, Matt Hollowell, Pat Schaub |
| 1999 |
Elijah Hammans, Tony Hollowell, Mike Hyde, Nate Lawrie, Luke Sayre, Dan Thompson |
| 2000 |
David Beckwith, Chris Eckhart, Jim Harrington, Jon Heise, Chris Oakley |
| 2001 |
Mark Willsey, Dan Hollowell, Joe Lutgring, Mike Doyle, Louie Stephon, Mike Perry |
| 2002 |
Tyler Warner, Kyle Stephenson, Peter Szostak, Tim Funke, Justin Agresta, Nick Jacobs, John Parden |
| 2003 |
Andrew Langferman, Kevin Trulock, Nick Marshall, Kyle Page, Eric Davis, Mike Collins |
| 2004 |
Luke Age, Nate Ashworth, Bill Cobb, Taylor Donnell, Andrew Hasty, Aaron Hollowell, Alex Lowe, Scott Lutgring, Andrew Noone, Andrew Pangallo, Chad Peterman, Tim Sergi, Brad Stephenson, Jason Werner |
| 2005 |
Rory Babb, Nick Banich, Andy Barkocy, Scot Bauman, Kyle Denny, Chad Hert, Sean McMahon, Chris Merkel, Nick Merkel, Bill Perry, Tom Shackleford, Max Weisenbach |
| 2006 |
Kirk Cahill, Paul Corsaro, Kyle Danhauer, Joe Britner, Mark Perkins, Andy Elliott, Matt Bova, Dom Fanelli |
| 2007 |
Ryan Danhauer, Bryan Elliott, Joe Elsener, Kyle McFerran, Jeff Soller, Zach Vandagrift, Sam Weisenbach |
| 2008 |
Dan Allen, Kevin Banich, Joe Fanelli, Mike Fries, Weston Kitley, Stephen Lutgring, Blake Milner, Connor Mullin |
| 2009 |
Brandon Banta, David Eckhart, Jimmy Eckhart, Charlie Kolisek, Jake Kovalsky, Kendell Miller, Michael Neylon, Evan Norris, Conor Pennell, Jimmy Pierle, Greg Scheaffer, Ray Stallings, Zach Teney, Tom Young |
Indiana All-State (Indiana Football Coaches Association)
| 1973 |
Dick Nalley, RB |
| 1975 |
Bob Bogardus, DT |
| 1977 |
Chad Huck, QB; Jeff Jourdan, WR |
| 1982 |
Dan Corsaro, DB (Voted All Star Game VP) |
| 1983 |
Greg Corsaro, LB; Andy Mappes, C-MG |
| 1984 |
Pat Spencer, G (Vote South Team Co-Captain); Dan Bauer, G-MG (voted Mental Attitude Award and South Team Co-Captain) |
| 1985 |
Steve Clements, OG; Joe Gillum, RB |
| 1988 |
Javier Zuluaga, LB; Chris Schott, C |
| 1989 |
Stan Lawrie, RB |
| 1992 |
Brian Zywicki, RB |
| 1993 |
Mike Bohn, RB; Jason Simmons, OT: Any Roell, NG; Christian Gaskill, LB |
| 1994 |
Rick Scott, TE; Brian Lauck, DB; Jeremy Stahley, LB |
| 1995 |
Jeff Roell, RB; Chris harvey, LB |
| 1996 |
Aaron Irwin, OT |
| 1997 |
Sean Schembra, RB: David Armbruster, OT |
| 1998 |
Steve Eckhart, LB; Pat Schaub, RB |
| 1999 |
Ryan Brizendine, NG; Nate Lawrie, TE |
| 2000 |
Chris Eckhart, TE; Rob Woelfel, OT |
| 2001 |
Mike Doyle, DB; Nick Himes, LB |
| 2002 |
Marcus Nalley, RB; Vince Logan, OT |
| 2003 |
Mark Evans, OG; Pat Kuntz, DE; Tim Sergi, RB; Jason Werner, DB |
| 2004 |
Casey Bolsega, OT; Billy Cobb, LB; Taylor Donnell, TE; Pat Kuntz, DE; Jason Werner, DB |
| 2005 |
Brandon Axum, DB; BIll Perry, LB |
| 2006 |
Joe Britner, TE; Kyle Danhauer, LB; Jake Kolisek, OG |
| 2007 |
Jack Hawkins, OT; John Keevers, LB |
| 2008 |
Luke Burkhart, DL; Drew Oechsle, LB; Weston Kitley, OT |
| 2009 |
Luke Burkhart, OG; Matt Masengale, OL; Tyler Mohr, RB |
All-State (A.P., U.P.I., Bloomington Herald-Telephone)
| 1975 |
Bob Kocher, WR |
| 1976 |
Chad Huck, QB; Jeff Jourdan, WR; Steve Stevason, DE; Tim Dant, OG/OT |
| 1977 |
Lou Annee, P |
| 1979 |
Bob Woods, MG |
| 1982 |
Greg Corsaro, LB; Kenny Gillum, RB; Andy Mappes, C-MG |
| 1983 |
Tim Annee, DB; Dan Bauer, MG; Jim House, T; Pat Spencer, G |
| 1984 |
Tim Annee, DB; Dan Bauer, MG; Joe Gillum, RB; Glen Huffman, TE; Sean Sander, T |
| 1985 |
Steve Clements, T; Joe Gillum, RB; Mike Irmer, DB; Tim Padgett, LB; Ron Roembke, DE |
| 1986 |
Eric Schott, T; Tony Farrell, DB |
| 1987 |
Mike Gillum, RB |
| 1988 |
Jim Roeder, OT; Javier Zuluaga, LB; Stan Lawrie, RB |
| 1989 |
Chris Toner, LB; Brian Sanders, DE; Stan Lawrie, RB |
| 1990 |
John Roeder, OT; Brian Sanders, DE; Chris Toner, LB |
| 1991 |
Jason Hoffman, DB |
| 1992 |
Brian Zywicki, DE |
| 1993 |
Jason Simmons, OT; Christian Gaskill, LB; Andy Roell, NG; Mike Tinder, PK; Mike Bohn, RB |
| 1994 |
Rick Scott, TE; Brian Lauck, DB; Jeremy Stahley, LB |
| 1995 |
Jeff Roell, RB; Jeff Allard, OT; Chris Harvey, LB |
| 1996 |
Aaron Irwin, OT |
| 1997 |
Sean Schembra, RB; David Armbruster, OT |
| 1998 |
Steve Eckhart, LB; Pat Schaub, RB |
| 1999 |
Greg Armbruster, LB; Ryan Brizendine, DT; Dustin Corbett, OT; Tommy Schembra, RB |
| 2000 |
Richie Nalley, RB; Rob Woelfel, OT |
| 2001 |
Tommy Kraft, LB; Jeff Westell, PK |
| 2002 |
Marcus Nalley, RB; Peter Szostak, DE; Ryan Mahin, LB |
| 2003 |
Mark Evans, OG; Kevin Trulock, PK; Pat Kuntz, DE; Tim Sergi, RB |
| 2004 |
Casey Bolsega, OT; Billy Cobb, LB; Taylor Donnell, TE; Pat Kuntz, DE; Jason Werner, DB |
| 2005 |
Brandon Axum, DB; Lyle Lawson, OG; Bill Perry, LB; Will Roush, OT; Max Weisenbach, C |
| 2006 |
Joe Britner, TE; Kyle Danhauer, LB; Jake Kolisek, OG |
| 2007 |
Jack Hawkins, OT; John Keevers, LB |
| 2008 |
Weston Kitley, OT; Drew Oechsle, LB |
| 2009 |
Luke Burkhart, OG; Matt Masengale OT; Tyler Mohr, RB |